
When voters choose a Sheriff, they are choosing someone to hold an extraordinary amount of power.
That is why, for me, this election comes down to one issue: training and experience.
It has nothing to do with how many football games a candidate has attended, how much money he has raised or given away, how many communities he has visited, or what school he attended.
Those things may tell you something about a person. They do not tell you whether that person is prepared to exercise the enormous authority entrusted to a Sheriff.
A Sheriff is not simply an administrator hired to run an office. The Sheriff leads an agency whose deputies have the authority to stop you on the highway, detain you, put you in handcuffs, arrest you, search you and your property, use force against you, and put you behind bars.
In very real terms, the Sheriff leads an agency with the power to take away your freedom.
That is an extraordinary amount of power to place in anyone’s hands. And with that power comes something equally important: knowing when and how the law allows you to use it.
Those limitations do not simply come from department policy. They are rooted in the Constitution.
Consider the Fourth Amendment and its protection against unreasonable searches and seizures.
Knowing the words of the Fourth Amendment is one thing. Knowing how to apply them in the real world is another.
When can an officer legally stop someone? How long can that person be detained? When can a vehicle be searched? When can officers enter someone’s home? When can property be seized? When does the evidence establish probable cause for an arrest?
Those are not academic questions for a Sheriff or deputy. They are decisions law enforcement officers make every day.
And getting them wrong can mean violating someone’s constitutional rights.
The consequences can also be enormous for taxpayers when unlawful actions lead to lawsuits and substantial settlements or judgments.
The badge gives someone the authority to enforce the law. Training and real-world experience provide the knowledge necessary to understand how that authority may lawfully be exercised.
Yes, anyone can read what the law says in a book.
Experience, however, teaches you how to apply the law when the answer is not obvious.
Law enforcement decisions are not always made behind a desk with unlimited time to research a statute or court decision. They are often made with incomplete information, conflicting stories, heightened emotions and, sometimes, only seconds to decide what to do.
That is where experience matters.
Sheriff Tyree Davis has spent approximately 23 years actually applying constitutional and criminal law in the real world. Tracy Story has never completed Basic Law Enforcement Training and has never independently served as a sworn law enforcement officer.
That difference matters.
And the issue becomes even more important when the inexperienced person is seeking to become Sheriff.
A lack of practical law enforcement experience at the top does not affect only one traffic stop, one arrest or one investigation. The Sheriff sets the standards for the entire agency.
The Sheriff determines what conduct is acceptable, what gets corrected, what warrants discipline, what is emphasized in training and who is placed in positions of leadership.
That raises a fundamental question:
How does someone recognize when deputies are exercising their authority incorrectly if that person has never been trained or experienced in exercising that authority himself?
How does he correct mistakes he may not have the experience to recognize?
And how does he properly lead people exercising governmental powers that he has never personally been trained to exercise?
Story and his supporters have pointed to the law enforcement experience of the team he has assembled, including claims of more than 100 years of combined experience.
That actually reinforces my point: experience matters.
But voters are not electing a team.
They are electing a Sheriff.
Every good Sheriff should surround himself with experienced people and listen to their advice. There is, however, a significant difference between seeking advice from experienced people and depending upon those people because the Sheriff lacks the training and experience necessary to independently evaluate their actions and recommendations.
Consider what happens when one of those experienced people makes a mistake.
The Sheriff ultimately has to recognize the problem, intervene when necessary, correct it and hold people accountable.
Those retired deputies would not be the Sheriff.
Tracy Story would be.
Everyone working beneath the Sheriff—including highly experienced deputies and command staff—must ultimately answer to someone capable of independently evaluating whether their actions are lawful, appropriate and consistent with the standards of the agency.
I believe that if members of Story’s experienced team evaluated the issue strictly from a law enforcement training perspective, they would have to acknowledge an uncomfortable reality: a newly hired deputy with Story’s level of formal law enforcement training and practical experience would not ordinarily be placed in command of an agency.
Yet voters are being asked to place him directly at the top.
When you cast a ballot for Sheriff, understand exactly what you are choosing.
You are not selecting a community ambassador, fundraiser, philanthropist or simply someone you believe is a nice person.
You are selecting the person who will be entrusted with enormous governmental authority over the citizens of Halifax County.
That includes oversight of the authority to detain people, search them and their property, arrest them, use force, seize property and take away their freedom.
That power should come with a deep understanding of the Constitution, criminal law, the limits of law enforcement authority and the real-world experience of actually applying those laws and limitations.
I will put my position as plainly as possible.
I believe it would be foolish to entrust that much power and authority to someone with no formal law enforcement training and no real-world experience independently exercising that authority.
Sheriff is not a position where someone should learn the fundamentals of law enforcement after taking office.
There is too much power involved, too much that can go wrong and too much individual liberty at stake.
For me, that leaves only one candidate in this race with the training and experience necessary to serve as Sheriff of Halifax County: the man who has already served in that position for the past four and a half years.
Sheriff Tyree Davis.
Jon Merritt
Publisher, Roanoke Valley Reporter







